Catherine Shearer logo
logo.png

or call/text 226-203-1243

Injured in a Car Accident While Working as a Police Officer? What Every Ontario Officer Needs to Know About Opting Out of WSIB

Thursday, November 06, 2025

Primary Blog/WSIB/Injured in a Car Accident While Working as a Police Officer? What Every Ontario Officer Needs to Know About Opting Out of WSIB

Many police officers assume that if they’re hurt on duty—or even driving to or from work—​WSIB is the only option.

It isn’t.

Ontario police officers have a unique legal right that most workers do not:

  • In many cases, you can opt out of WSIB and sue the at-fault driver directly.

This choice can dramatically affect your future, especially if the injury impacts your ability to return to full policing duties. And once you sign the wrong election, you often can’t undo it.

Let’s break this down clearly and without legal jargon.

When WSIB Applies to Police Officers

If you’re:

  • In a cruiser (marked or unmarked)
  • Driving to or from your shift
  • Travelling between stations or units
  • On scene at a call
  • Hit while directing traffic or responding

WSIB usually treats the accident as in the course of employment.

​WSIB may cover:

  • Treatment
  • Some wage loss
  • Permanent impairment benefits

But for many officers—especially those with long-term injuries—WSIB does not come close to covering the true financial impact.

A Hard Truth Many Officers Don’t Realize

Some officers heal quickly and return to full duties. Others don’t.

A very real scenario looks like this:

  • An officer is hit by another driver
  • They recover enough to work, but not to return to active policing
  • Permanent restrictions → reassigned to desk or administrative duties
  • Their career path changes overnight

Suddenly...

  • Overtime disappears
  • Promotion tracks change
  • Specialized units become impossible
  • Pension growth is affected
  • Job satisfaction is gone

WSIB may still call this a “successful return to work,” even though the officer will never patrol again.

​That’s exactly why the right to opt out exists.

When You Can Opt Out of WSIB

Here is the key rule most officers don’t know:

  • You can only sue if the at-fault driver was NOT in the course of their own employment at the time of the collision.

Meaning:

  • A civilian driving their own car → usually eligible
  • A driver running personal errands → eligible
  • Someone commuting to or from work → eligible
  • Anyone not actively working for an employer at the time → eligible

This is extremely common in motor-vehicle collisions (MVCs) involving police. Most crashes involve civilians, not commercial or municipal workers. So many officers do have the right to elect out of WSIB.

​If you elect out, you may be able to recover:

  • Pain and suffering
  • Full past and future income loss
  • Overtime and premium pay losses
  • Loss of promotion and specialty-unit opportunities
  • Pension losses
  • Medical, rehab, and psychological treatment costs
  • Housekeeping or personal care costs
  • Future care needs

For an officer who ends up in a permanent desk role, this can make a major difference in financial security and quality of life.

When You Should NOT Opt Out

Opting out is not always the right call. It may be risky if:

  • A police vehicle or your own vehicle was at fault
  • Fault is unclear or shared
  • Injuries are minor and fully healed
  • There is no available insurance coverage for a lawsuit

This is a decision you should not make alone. Once your election is signed, it is often final.

Timelines Matter—And They Are Easy to Miss

This is where many officers lose their rights.

  • You usually have 3 months from receiving the “right to sue” letter to make your election
  • You have 2 years from the date of the collision to start a lawsuit

If those deadlines pass, your ability to sue can disappear completely—even if your injuries get worse later or if you discover you’ll never return to active duty. Early legal advice protects your options.

Why You Should Contact a Lawyer Before You Decide

Police officers are used to being self-reliant, but this is one decision you shouldn't try to navigate alone.

A lawyer experienced with police injury cases can:

  • Confirm whether you qualify to opt out
  • Calculate the real long-term impact on your earnings and pension
  • Preserve your right to sue
  • Communicate with WSIB and insurers
  • Protect you from missed deadlines
  • Make sure your future is protected—not just your immediate medical care

This is not about being litigious. It’s about protecting your career, your income, and your family.

What to Do If You’re an Injured Officer

  • Report the collision and document symptoms.
  • Get medical assessment and treatment.
  • File WSIB forms.
  • Call a lawyer before signing any election.
  • Do not assume you will get better on your own.
  • Do not wait until the deadlines are near.

You would protect any victim of a collision. You deserve the same level of protection when it happens to you.

Free Consultation for Ontario Police Officers

If you are an active-duty officer injured in a motor vehicle collision—on duty or travelling to or from work—please reach out. You’ll get clear, honest advice about whether opting out makes sense in your situation.

​This article was written by Personal Injury Lawyer, Catherine Shearer. For additional information, please do not hesitate to contact her at catherine.shearer@mckenzielake.com or visit her Instagram page @guelphinjurylawyer.

Headshot image of attorney Catherine Shearer

Hi, I'm Catherine

Ontario Personal Injury Attorney

I help Ontarians who've suffered financial hardship due to auto accidents, traumatic brain injuries, long-term disability, & other injuries to protect their financial future.

​If you or a loved one have suffered an injury and would like to speak to an attorney about your options, don't hesitate to schedule a free consultation or join a free informational session.

Book A Consultation With

Guelph's Trusted Personal Injury Lawyer

​If you've been hurt in an accident in Ontario, it pays to have Catherine in your corner. With her compassionate approach she'll take the time to understand your situation so that she can then fight to protect your future. 

When booking your consultation, you can rest easy knowing that:

  • There is no obligation if you take a consultation. This is simply your chance to share your story with Catherine and decide if she's the right lawyer to represent you.
  • Everything you share is completely confidential.
  • You pay nothing out of pocket. If you decide to work with Catherine, her fees are covered as a percentage of the verdict or settlement. She only gets paid when you win!

CONNECT WITH CATHERINE TODAY

CONNECT WITH CATHERINE TODAY

Request your free consultation

Providing this information will help me to best prepare for your free consultation. I appreciate you taking the time to tell me your story.

By providing your number, you agree to receive communications, including text messages, from McKenzie Lake. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency varies.

Guelph Office

Suite 300 100 Stone Road West
Guelph, ON N1G 5L3
Phone: 226-203-1243

​Fax: 519-826-4332

London Office

Suite 1800 140 Fullarton Street
London, ON N6A 5P2
Phone: 226-203-1243
Fax: 519-672-2674

© 2025 McKenzie Lake Lawyers LLP. All Rights Reserved.